Culture, Music

Review: Samantha Jade


Samantha Jade - album by Samantha JadeThe debut album from Samantha Jade follows the 25 year old’s journey through Australia’s X-Factor final. Featuring re-recorded studio tracks of some of Samantha’s performances on the show including UFO, Breakeven, Wide Awake and Free Fallin’, as well as recordings of her standout performance and number #1 iTunes song, Heartless and her winning single, What You’ve Done To Me.

Well, well. Samantha Jade is the Australian Kelly Clarkson, winner of their X-Factor talent show, a pretty pop-poppette with a decent voice and a new album recorded, apparently, in two days to capitalise on the win. Only one problem; she’s not got the expressive range or the charisma to be a Clarkson. Or Britney, or Rihanna, or Katy Perry.

Recording her X Factor scores must have seemed like a sure fire winner, but compared to the solid-gold originals, seems now like a poor management choice.

Jade acquits herself well enough through this collection entirely of covers, giving respectable, if forgettable renditions. She warbles through the uptempo numbers, sounding like one of those rent-a-vocal voices that producers put over some synth lines and drum machines for an Ibiza dance track. Hm, like David Guetta perhaps, who she worked with during her US attempt to get famous before an ignominious return home and X-Factor. What You’ve Done to Me motors along perfectly well as a bit of sparkly electro; lyrically unremarkable, light-weight disposable pop.

Heartless (original by Kanye West) is a power ballad with orchestration, a cut-price Bond theme, where Jade’s voice seems to be helium-filled, with a lot of vibrato.

Wide Awake is a cover of Katy Perry’s single from last year, adequate enough, but lacking Perry’s force of personality (if you can say that about Smurfette and the weird half-deer, half-alien woman from that pop video – but Perry can sing more than a bit).

Free-fallin’ (Zoe Badwi, note title with a laid-back apostrophe) is another identi-kit dance track. The Tom Petty song of the same name would have been more challenging.

Every Time is a cover of a familiar ballad made famous by Britney and another demonstration of why you shouldn’t go up against big-name International artists by covering recent hits. Britney may have given up proper singing in favour of auto-tuned mega-production, but by comparison, Jade’s voice seems lightweight and shallow.

Run to You (Whitney Houston) goes all Christina Aguilera in its’ vocal stylings, with an odd production that really puts her warbling voice somewhere back in the eighties.

Scream is borrowed from Usher as a straight daytime radio remake. UFO (Sneaky Sound System) is a repro’ knock-off which works only if you don’t remember the original.

Jade then falls into the trap of covering a recent Clarkson song – Stronger – and falls badly in the comparison. The backing track is second rate and Jade doesn’t hit you in the face with a fist of pure energy like pocket-rocket Clarkson.

Where Have You Been is a Rihanna song that seems to have been speeded up to save an extra studio hour. Breakeven belongs to the Script and it was just as irritating when they did it.

Credit where it’s due, as albums go, it’s a solid selection of narrative songs, like them or not. But each time, Jade falls short in comparison to recent originals by global superstars. We’ve yet to hear what she can do interpreting some original material. We’ll have to see what the ‘difficult second album’ brings. SC

Related: Review: Kelly Clarkson – Stronger

About Sue Corsten

Sue Corsten is a film and TV make-up artist based in the UK.

Discussion

5 thoughts on “Review: Samantha Jade

  1. I like her voice much better than faked up Britney.

    Posted by Cis Sausa | December 28, 2012, 2:16 pm
  2. thanks for the article… I was wondering who she was.

    Posted by carol zinhajardim | December 28, 2012, 6:10 pm
  3. I didn’t even know who she was until 10 minutes ago…then I searched for her and read this article. Do you know anything about vocal range and music in general…AT ALL? From the way you write, I’m guessing you don’t. Britney Spears has under a 3 octave vocal range – she is not even in the same category as the other girls you mentioned. The only reason she is a top performer is because of her song choice and her recognizable voice and stage theatrics. Kelly Clarkson, while having a high and low voice, cannot hit all the notes in between and does not have that big of a range. Katy Perry uses her nasal passages to simulate a high head voice, but she cannot do it successfully live. Rihanna…she has more overall range that the others you listed, but she is still not comparable to the range of Samantha Jade. Jade’s range is more comparable to that of Carrie Underwood, Adele, or on her best days, a young Christina Aguilera. By comparing her to the ones you mentioned, you are comparing apples to oranges. If I had to guess, I’d say Samantha has a 3 – 3.5 octave vocal range, as she can hit the mid register and high head voice just fine, but does have a little trouble emulating low notes.

    Posted by Tommy | March 6, 2013, 3:59 pm
    • Tommy: harsh. Have you read the content of the article, like… AT ALL?? From the way you write, I’m guessing you haven’t.

      Having re-read Sue’s post, she wasn’t writing a technical critique of Ms. Jade’s singing ability, merely the self-inflicted injury of releasing a covers album and putting her wall-of-bland up against International A-listers. Certainly Perry can’t do it live (see any of her MTV Award train-wrecks), and Clarkson can’t hit all the mid-notes, but Clarkson can blow the roof off a venue by sheer force of personality, as can Aguilera. And if you want to challenge the auto-tuned production machine of Ms Spears, you better be able to afford it.

      If you’d like to write an imformed technical critique of the pop music industry, I’m sure the Editors would take a look at it. AJS

      Posted by Allan J. Smithie | March 7, 2013, 2:26 pm

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: Full Circle Magazine Issue 68 Out Now « Everything Express - January 1, 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Twitter Updates

Follow us on Twitter @EverythingExpre

Find Us on Facebook

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Library

BBC World News

BBC World News
Opens the BBC World News page.
%d bloggers like this: